Normally, I consider it a positive attribute to be able to see the world in shades of gray. It's rare that anything's clearly one way or another. There are always several sides to most arguments, and I often bristle when people try to reduce the complexities of a debate down to a single mantra, slogan, or viewpoint.
That's why I love sports. It's one of the few things in life that's black and white. You win or you lose (ties are like kissing your sister). You score more runs/points/goals: You win, and everyone's happy. You get beat on the scoreboard: You lose, and you feel shame. But there's always a next game waiting, and you might win that one. Unless you're a Raider fan.
Being a sports fan is also very cut and dried. You root for your team, win or lose. You don't switch in the middle of the game when your team starts losing. You put up with lots of losing in the hopes that one day you'll be rewarded with your loyalty.
And one more thing: You root for the team that plays in the city nearest where you're from. You don't get to pick and choose. You don't get to throw darts at a board. You just don't.
This seems like a stupid, arbitrary rule. But that's the thing about sports: they're stupid and arbitrary. That's why it's easy to have a black-and-white set of values to abide by. Ultimately, we're all just "rooting for laundry," as Jerry Seinfeld puts it. There's no nuance to this. You grow up in an area, you root for the teams from that place, no matter how badly they may suck. You'll have some good years and some bad years, but no true fan abandons his or her roots in search of greener pastures.
There are only three exceptions to this rule:
1. Your parent grew up a huge sports fan in another area, has since moved, and has indoctrinated you as a fan of his childhood team. Sports fandom is like religion; it's passed down to you, and there's not much you can do about it. Unlike religion, which is actually an important life decision which should be based on careful study and personal beliefs, you don't get to change because your current team's performance isn't satisfying you. Again, this may seem stupid and rigid, but that's the code of sports.
2. The team you grew up rooting for moved away. You are now not beholden to them and may pick from any other team. There is a caveat to this: the more historically successful/popular a team is, the more douchey it is to pick them as your team of choice. Anyone can root for the Lakers, the Cowboys, or the Yankees year after year; it takes someone with cojones to randomly choose the Houston Astros, Seattle Seahawks, or Columbus Blue Jackets. Coincidentally, I've never known anyone from L.A. who was a Clipper fan or raised their kids as a Clipper fan. Always the Lakers. I'm sure it's solely due to the fact that the Lakers were there first, not because L.A. sports fans are largely frontrunning bandwagon posers who can't even support a football team.
3. You grew up in an area without a pro team anywhere nearby. Montana, Hawaii, Mississippi, etc. You are also a free agent. See #2 above.
There are no other exceptions to this rule. You can't say stuff like "I just really like Shaq, so I pull for the Lakers." It's fine to really like Shaq, except when he's playing your hometown team. Then he's the enemy. I was a huge Barry Sanders fan growing up, but when the Lions played the Niners, I wanted S.F. to shut him down. Ditto Tony Gwynn, Kirby Puckett, Mario Lemieux, Kevin Johnson, etc.
It doesn't make any sense to root for a team just because a player you admire toils for them. Players move around all the time. Even in the rare cases when someone like Puckett, Gwynn, or Magic Johnson plays his whole career with one team, that's just the luck of the draw. If that player had been drafted by someone else, he would've played just as hard for that team. Kobe Bryant is the notable, petulant, rapist exception that proves the rule.
Players don't care about what color the uniform is they put on. They play for money first and competitive glory second. Fans are the ones who care about the name on the front of the uniform; the players worry about the one on their backs.
Again, we're rooting for laundry. But there's honor in that. I wrote before that the rules of sports fandom are silly and arbitrary, but allow me to give a rationale for the idea that one should root for his or her local team exclusively.
Sports bind a community together. It's a common touchstone we can all share. When things are bad, we commiserate. When they're good, we are hopeful and optimistic. When they're great (which hasn't been for a while now), we hug total strangers in bars and experience a kind of communal euphoria.
Even within the community, there's diversity. Each fan base develops an identity. There's the eternally hopeful and knowledgeable Warrior crowd, the equally hopeful but increasingly nonexistent A's patrons, the proud but unsatisfied Shark followers, the sophisticated Giants crew with their blackberries at the ready, the Cal fans who absolutely know that the next disaster is around the corner, even as they hope against all hope for the best, the wine-and-cheese bourgeois Niner fans who mix easily with the fading blue collar San Francisco element, and of course the unwashed Raider masses, with their felony convictions and ref-hating paranoia.
For as much grief as I give Raider fans, at least they're loyal. I would much rather talk sports with one of them than a lifelong Bay Area resident who professes to love the Lakers. Because that person is not a real sports fan. Oh sure, those "fans" may get happy when their adopted, far-away team wins and dejected when they lose, but it's not real. It's not earned. It's not respectable. It's a cop out. They might as well be rooting for another region's weather.
A huge part of being a fan is giving fans of another squad grief. When I find out that someone's breaking the rules of fandom by rooting for a team he or she has no right to, I instantly break off the conversation. Because the person just doesn't get it. You want to talk smack to me about a team you chose because it's successful, while I put up with the Giants' woes (and lack of a single championship) year after year, and act like we're fan equals?
No, we're not. Now shut up.
"But I've always liked the Lakers/Cowboys/Yankees! I'm a true fan!"
No, you're not. Now shut up.
Monday, October 5, 2009
Sunday, October 4, 2009
Bay Area Sports Fail
On the occasion of Cal's pipe-wrenching at the hands of USC, guaranteeing another disappointing season, it occurred to me that sports fans in the Bay Area have put a lot of dedication and dollars into extraordinarily minimal results.
It's now been almost 15 years since the Bay's last championship in any sport, when the Niners dusted the Chargers in January of 1995. Fifteen years. We have two football teams, two baseball teams, two major conference colleges and assorted minor ones, a hockey team, and a team that, on its surface, pretends to be an NBA franchise.
Before anyone starts bringing up the now-defunct Sabercats or Stanford women's basketball, I'm limiting this lament to sports that people actually care about.
I realize now that I was spoiled while growing up. One of my earliest childhood memories was "The Catch," Dwight Clark's soaring, iconic grab in the back of the endzone that beat the hated Cowboys and kicked off the 49ers dynasty. Five Super Bowl victories in the next 13 years made me think things were always going to be this way.
The Bay's other pro sports teams pulled their weight during the 80's as well. The Giants and A's played each other in the '89 series, assuring that the champion would reside in the Bay. The wrong team won, but it was an exciting time to be alive in these parts. Even the Warriors showed flashes of brilliance. "Run TMC" never got past the second round of the playoffs, but they were always competitive and fun to watch. Thankfully, the Raiders were in L.A. for most of this period, so their Super Bowl win was far less annoying. We didn't have to deal with any riots, as I recall.
The 90's brought the Sharks, and other than the Niners' last gasp, a whole lot of losing that has mostly continued unimpeded to this day. Sure, every once in a while somebody makes a run, like the Raiders in 2003 (which was hilarious) and the Giants in 2002 (which I still can't even really talk about), but for the most part it's been 15 years of pain and torture. Even when a team seems great, like the Sharks last year, they find a way to negate all the good times by flaming out with an embarrassing loss in the playoffs.
Meanwhile, except for one short-lived burst of success in 2007, the Warriors have been a national joke. Sigh.
So, why do we put ourselves through this? At least I know what glory tastes like. My teenage students aren't old enough to recall a time when Bay Area sports weren't a giant mess of steaming feces. Yet they are far more positive than I am. They constantly think that a championship is right around the corner, like Charley Brown running up to kick the football, over and over again. They often tell me to "have faith," one of my least favorite sayings, which is proven wrong over and over again.
More often than not, it's not all that fun to be a sports fan around here. Yet, I'm proud of us. Our teams suck, but we persevere. We know that when one of our teams actually does come through, all the torment and angst will have made us stronger. It will all have been worth it. After all, "What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly." -Thomas Paine
Consider this an ode to all the long-suffering Bay Area sports fans. Even Raider fans, in prison or on parole. We're all in this misery together.
As for those Bay Area residents who are reading this and saying, "Yeah, but at least my Lakers won last year," there's a special spot in hell reserved for fans of your particular stripe. Your blog is coming tomorrow.
It's now been almost 15 years since the Bay's last championship in any sport, when the Niners dusted the Chargers in January of 1995. Fifteen years. We have two football teams, two baseball teams, two major conference colleges and assorted minor ones, a hockey team, and a team that, on its surface, pretends to be an NBA franchise.
Before anyone starts bringing up the now-defunct Sabercats or Stanford women's basketball, I'm limiting this lament to sports that people actually care about.
I realize now that I was spoiled while growing up. One of my earliest childhood memories was "The Catch," Dwight Clark's soaring, iconic grab in the back of the endzone that beat the hated Cowboys and kicked off the 49ers dynasty. Five Super Bowl victories in the next 13 years made me think things were always going to be this way.
The Bay's other pro sports teams pulled their weight during the 80's as well. The Giants and A's played each other in the '89 series, assuring that the champion would reside in the Bay. The wrong team won, but it was an exciting time to be alive in these parts. Even the Warriors showed flashes of brilliance. "Run TMC" never got past the second round of the playoffs, but they were always competitive and fun to watch. Thankfully, the Raiders were in L.A. for most of this period, so their Super Bowl win was far less annoying. We didn't have to deal with any riots, as I recall.
The 90's brought the Sharks, and other than the Niners' last gasp, a whole lot of losing that has mostly continued unimpeded to this day. Sure, every once in a while somebody makes a run, like the Raiders in 2003 (which was hilarious) and the Giants in 2002 (which I still can't even really talk about), but for the most part it's been 15 years of pain and torture. Even when a team seems great, like the Sharks last year, they find a way to negate all the good times by flaming out with an embarrassing loss in the playoffs.
Meanwhile, except for one short-lived burst of success in 2007, the Warriors have been a national joke. Sigh.
So, why do we put ourselves through this? At least I know what glory tastes like. My teenage students aren't old enough to recall a time when Bay Area sports weren't a giant mess of steaming feces. Yet they are far more positive than I am. They constantly think that a championship is right around the corner, like Charley Brown running up to kick the football, over and over again. They often tell me to "have faith," one of my least favorite sayings, which is proven wrong over and over again.
More often than not, it's not all that fun to be a sports fan around here. Yet, I'm proud of us. Our teams suck, but we persevere. We know that when one of our teams actually does come through, all the torment and angst will have made us stronger. It will all have been worth it. After all, "What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly." -Thomas Paine
Consider this an ode to all the long-suffering Bay Area sports fans. Even Raider fans, in prison or on parole. We're all in this misery together.
As for those Bay Area residents who are reading this and saying, "Yeah, but at least my Lakers won last year," there's a special spot in hell reserved for fans of your particular stripe. Your blog is coming tomorrow.
Saturday, October 3, 2009
"American Idiot" and my annoyingly small bladder
As I noted in yesterday's blog, I went to see the Green Day musical last night. I had never been to the Berkeley Repertory Theatre before, but I'm definitely a fan now. They have a great outdoor patio with a mini bar, which was serving specialty cocktails named after some of the songs from American Idiot.
It was imperative that my friend Derek and I sampled them all, of course. Would've been kind of irresponsible of us to try the "Letterbomb" and not know what "St.Jimmy" had to offer. We had one outside and took one into the theatre, using the paper cup the friendly bartender provided.
I made a point of making a pitstop before going upstairs to our seats, and I'd already gone once at the restaurant beforehand. When I got to the seats, my wife mentioned that she wished she'd gone also, but alas! It was too late; the lights were going down. I smirked with self-satisfaction.
The show was fantastic. I hadn't listened to American Idiot all the way through in a while, and I'd forgotten that the first five or so songs are all total home runs. There's a bit of plot shoehorned in between the music, but for the most part the show consists of one or more lead singers with a bunch of backing dancers/vocalists throwing themselves all over the eye-popping set, accompanied by a live band. I am more convinced than ever that "Jesus of Suburbia" is one of the greatest rock n' roll anthems ever written. Not in the past decade. Ever.
The show was an hour-and-a-half with no intermission, and right around the 45-minute mark, my bladder starting making its presence felt. However, we were in the middle of a cramped aisle, and there were signs on the way in that stated that if you left your seat, you wouldn't be reseated until an "appropriate moment," and possibly not in the same seat you left. I decided to ride it out.
I knew the album pretty well, and they were playing it chronologically. I couldn't see my watch in the dark, but there were only four or five songs left. I was confident I could make it through, even with the mammoth "Homecoming" looming.
Then they launched into "Know Your Enemy." What??? That wasn't part of the deal! That's not on American Idiot! When "21 Guns" tipped off, I knew I was hosed. I unbuckled my belt to alleviate the pressure. I squirmed and changed positions. I refused to think about any kind of liquid. All to no avail. I made it through "Wake Me Up When September Ends" and had to make a run for it.
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. Sweet relief.
I sat in a chair in the walkway after I came back so I wouldn't disturb the people I'd had to get past again and enjoyed the finale, the criminally overlooked "Whatsername."
Afterward, we were dissecting the show, and everyone else was talking about how amazing it was the whole way through. I mentioned that I couldn't really keep track of the plot, and they all looked at me in disbelief and started pointing out all these things that had happened that I hadn't remembered. I'd been in agony for 25 minutes and then spent 5 minutes going to the john.
Oh, and my wife held her water the whole time, no problem. I officially have a smaller bladder than a pregnant chick.
It was imperative that my friend Derek and I sampled them all, of course. Would've been kind of irresponsible of us to try the "Letterbomb" and not know what "St.Jimmy" had to offer. We had one outside and took one into the theatre, using the paper cup the friendly bartender provided.
I made a point of making a pitstop before going upstairs to our seats, and I'd already gone once at the restaurant beforehand. When I got to the seats, my wife mentioned that she wished she'd gone also, but alas! It was too late; the lights were going down. I smirked with self-satisfaction.
The show was fantastic. I hadn't listened to American Idiot all the way through in a while, and I'd forgotten that the first five or so songs are all total home runs. There's a bit of plot shoehorned in between the music, but for the most part the show consists of one or more lead singers with a bunch of backing dancers/vocalists throwing themselves all over the eye-popping set, accompanied by a live band. I am more convinced than ever that "Jesus of Suburbia" is one of the greatest rock n' roll anthems ever written. Not in the past decade. Ever.
The show was an hour-and-a-half with no intermission, and right around the 45-minute mark, my bladder starting making its presence felt. However, we were in the middle of a cramped aisle, and there were signs on the way in that stated that if you left your seat, you wouldn't be reseated until an "appropriate moment," and possibly not in the same seat you left. I decided to ride it out.
I knew the album pretty well, and they were playing it chronologically. I couldn't see my watch in the dark, but there were only four or five songs left. I was confident I could make it through, even with the mammoth "Homecoming" looming.
Then they launched into "Know Your Enemy." What??? That wasn't part of the deal! That's not on American Idiot! When "21 Guns" tipped off, I knew I was hosed. I unbuckled my belt to alleviate the pressure. I squirmed and changed positions. I refused to think about any kind of liquid. All to no avail. I made it through "Wake Me Up When September Ends" and had to make a run for it.
Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh. Sweet relief.
I sat in a chair in the walkway after I came back so I wouldn't disturb the people I'd had to get past again and enjoyed the finale, the criminally overlooked "Whatsername."
Afterward, we were dissecting the show, and everyone else was talking about how amazing it was the whole way through. I mentioned that I couldn't really keep track of the plot, and they all looked at me in disbelief and started pointing out all these things that had happened that I hadn't remembered. I'd been in agony for 25 minutes and then spent 5 minutes going to the john.
Oh, and my wife held her water the whole time, no problem. I officially have a smaller bladder than a pregnant chick.
Friday, October 2, 2009
My long, enduring relationship with Green Day
Tonight I'm going to the Berkeley Repertory Theatre to see American Idiot: The Musical (that might not actually be what it's called, but close enough) with my best friend from high school and our wives. I'm really excited about both seeing Derek, who lives in Seattle, and the performance based on my favorite album by one of my favorite bands.
It also got me thinking how music, or more specifically following the progress of a certain band, is a great way to mark "the time of your life," if you'll permit me an obvious allusion. I was in high school when Green Day first started getting noticed in the East Bay Area. They played shows in Vallejo, Martinez, and of course, Berkeley. Not that I attended any of these shows, mind you. I was waaaaay too uncool for that. Plus, I was scared of Vallejo. Still am. But some of my more adventurous classmates went, and wouldn't shut up about this pop punk trio that, like, totally rocked.
Their breakout (but not first) album, Dookie, came out during my senior year. Like pretty much everyone else in my generation, I bought it (on cassette...unlike almost everyone else in the mid-90's, I hadn't quite switched to cd yet...I told you I was uncool) and played it until it fell apart.
UNLIKE everyone else in my generation, that summer I rode on a Southwest airlines flight (choose your own seats!) from San Diego to Oakland while sitting next to the three members of Green Day and their road manager. It remains my most prolonged brush with fame, although they really weren't all that famous in August of 1994. Sure, they had two hit singles ("Basketcase" and "Longview"), but average patrons of the friendly skies had no idea who they were.
In fact, the only reason my sister and I were able to sit next to the guys was that they looked to the untrained eye like a bunch of punker misfits. Lead singer Billie Joe Armstrong reinforced this image by loudly warbling his version of Tom Petty's "Refugee," playing along on an acoustic guitar, waiting for the plane in the terminal. Once we were in flight, he staggered up to the intercom and attempted to ask the entire plane if any of the stewardesses could bring him "another bag of penis." He couldn't work the handset, though. In retrospect, he very well may have been high.
Meanwhile, drummer Tre Cool spoke constantly in a falsetto and bugged my sister about letting him have her Hawaiian hat, which he absconded with at the conclusion of the flight. Now that I think about it, those guys were definitely high.
I had a long conversation with the most mellow (but probably also high) member of the crew, bassist Mike Dirnt. We talked about music; I specifically remember him saying that The Offspring's "Keep 'Em Separated" had taken him a long time to get used to, but now he liked it. When he found out I was going to college at UC Davis in the fall, he told me about how they'd played the coffeehouse there a bunch of times. They'd also played Woodstock '94 a couple weeks earlier, and their set had ended in a massive mud fight with fans. Some in the press construed it as violent and agitated, but both Mike and Billie Joe claimed everyone was having fun.
Mike also spoke of his East Bay roots and knowing Billie Joe from growing up together. He talked glowingly of his girlfriend, whom he claimed he couldn't wait to see and would be waiting at the gate in Oakland (remember, this was pre-9/11).
The flight was over all too quickly, but as my sister and I walked off the jetway, I have two enduring memories. One was the quizzical (and slightly worried) expression on my stepdad's face, as he tried to figure out why we were getting off the plane, kidding and laughing, with three spiky-headed, pierced musicians. The other was Mike, rushing into his purple-haired girlfriend's arms, and then looking back at us and mouthing, "See, this is her!" Because I can still picture that moment, Mike Dirnt will never be a spoiled, arrogant rock star to me, no matter what else he does with his life.
As I look back on that time, I see parallels with my life and Green Day's career arc. They were on the cusp of superstardom; I was about to experience the glory and upheaval of my freshman year of college. Ok, so maybe it's a reach, but we were both young and dumb, and the road wasn't always smooth. I bought every new album (one of the first things I did in college was to buy a cd player) and drove down from Davis to see a couple of their shows. I even reviewed their more mature-sounding cd Nimrod for the school newspaper and got paid for it, something I never would've thought possible. We were growing up together, it seemed.
Green Day's popularity waned a bit during the late 90's and early 2000's, as they struggled to find their direction. This time coincided with my early-to-mid 20's, and the less said about that era, the better. I moved to the City in 2003 and met my future wife. Green Day roared back with the titanic American Idiot in 2004, and every sane person hated George W. Bush to the tune of the band's magnificent soundtrack of disaffected youth.
A couple weeks ago, some friends of mine saw Mike Dirnt eating at one of my favorite restaurants from childhood, El Charro, in Lafayette. I still go there whenever I can. But things have changed, as they have for the guys in the band. They're nearing their forties, and all of them have at least one marriage and progeny to their credit.
My friend Derek also has kids, and I have one on the way. We don't get to hang out as much as we used to. I still love Green Day, but I haven't been to one of their concerts in probably 10 years; I'd be the oldest person there who wasn't chaperoning a teenager.
But you know what? Just like the band, we can still do it when it matters. As an added benefit of growing up, we no longer need our fake i.d.'s and have disposable income to spend on expensive cocktails. Tonight, we're gonna sing till our lungs give out.
"I'M THE SON OF RAGE AND LOVE!!!"
It also got me thinking how music, or more specifically following the progress of a certain band, is a great way to mark "the time of your life," if you'll permit me an obvious allusion. I was in high school when Green Day first started getting noticed in the East Bay Area. They played shows in Vallejo, Martinez, and of course, Berkeley. Not that I attended any of these shows, mind you. I was waaaaay too uncool for that. Plus, I was scared of Vallejo. Still am. But some of my more adventurous classmates went, and wouldn't shut up about this pop punk trio that, like, totally rocked.
Their breakout (but not first) album, Dookie, came out during my senior year. Like pretty much everyone else in my generation, I bought it (on cassette...unlike almost everyone else in the mid-90's, I hadn't quite switched to cd yet...I told you I was uncool) and played it until it fell apart.
UNLIKE everyone else in my generation, that summer I rode on a Southwest airlines flight (choose your own seats!) from San Diego to Oakland while sitting next to the three members of Green Day and their road manager. It remains my most prolonged brush with fame, although they really weren't all that famous in August of 1994. Sure, they had two hit singles ("Basketcase" and "Longview"), but average patrons of the friendly skies had no idea who they were.
In fact, the only reason my sister and I were able to sit next to the guys was that they looked to the untrained eye like a bunch of punker misfits. Lead singer Billie Joe Armstrong reinforced this image by loudly warbling his version of Tom Petty's "Refugee," playing along on an acoustic guitar, waiting for the plane in the terminal. Once we were in flight, he staggered up to the intercom and attempted to ask the entire plane if any of the stewardesses could bring him "another bag of penis." He couldn't work the handset, though. In retrospect, he very well may have been high.
Meanwhile, drummer Tre Cool spoke constantly in a falsetto and bugged my sister about letting him have her Hawaiian hat, which he absconded with at the conclusion of the flight. Now that I think about it, those guys were definitely high.
I had a long conversation with the most mellow (but probably also high) member of the crew, bassist Mike Dirnt. We talked about music; I specifically remember him saying that The Offspring's "Keep 'Em Separated" had taken him a long time to get used to, but now he liked it. When he found out I was going to college at UC Davis in the fall, he told me about how they'd played the coffeehouse there a bunch of times. They'd also played Woodstock '94 a couple weeks earlier, and their set had ended in a massive mud fight with fans. Some in the press construed it as violent and agitated, but both Mike and Billie Joe claimed everyone was having fun.
Mike also spoke of his East Bay roots and knowing Billie Joe from growing up together. He talked glowingly of his girlfriend, whom he claimed he couldn't wait to see and would be waiting at the gate in Oakland (remember, this was pre-9/11).
The flight was over all too quickly, but as my sister and I walked off the jetway, I have two enduring memories. One was the quizzical (and slightly worried) expression on my stepdad's face, as he tried to figure out why we were getting off the plane, kidding and laughing, with three spiky-headed, pierced musicians. The other was Mike, rushing into his purple-haired girlfriend's arms, and then looking back at us and mouthing, "See, this is her!" Because I can still picture that moment, Mike Dirnt will never be a spoiled, arrogant rock star to me, no matter what else he does with his life.
As I look back on that time, I see parallels with my life and Green Day's career arc. They were on the cusp of superstardom; I was about to experience the glory and upheaval of my freshman year of college. Ok, so maybe it's a reach, but we were both young and dumb, and the road wasn't always smooth. I bought every new album (one of the first things I did in college was to buy a cd player) and drove down from Davis to see a couple of their shows. I even reviewed their more mature-sounding cd Nimrod for the school newspaper and got paid for it, something I never would've thought possible. We were growing up together, it seemed.
Green Day's popularity waned a bit during the late 90's and early 2000's, as they struggled to find their direction. This time coincided with my early-to-mid 20's, and the less said about that era, the better. I moved to the City in 2003 and met my future wife. Green Day roared back with the titanic American Idiot in 2004, and every sane person hated George W. Bush to the tune of the band's magnificent soundtrack of disaffected youth.
A couple weeks ago, some friends of mine saw Mike Dirnt eating at one of my favorite restaurants from childhood, El Charro, in Lafayette. I still go there whenever I can. But things have changed, as they have for the guys in the band. They're nearing their forties, and all of them have at least one marriage and progeny to their credit.
My friend Derek also has kids, and I have one on the way. We don't get to hang out as much as we used to. I still love Green Day, but I haven't been to one of their concerts in probably 10 years; I'd be the oldest person there who wasn't chaperoning a teenager.
But you know what? Just like the band, we can still do it when it matters. As an added benefit of growing up, we no longer need our fake i.d.'s and have disposable income to spend on expensive cocktails. Tonight, we're gonna sing till our lungs give out.
"I'M THE SON OF RAGE AND LOVE!!!"
Thursday, October 1, 2009
Blog-a-Day Month
For the past two years, my friends Lance and Scott have issued a challenge: Blog once a day for the entire month of October. These two rascals have managed to do it both times, with each declaring himself the winner at the end of the term (although I believe Lance refers to himself as a two-time champion because he declared it first).
Anyway, there are a whole bunch of rules, but I don't feel like re-posting them. I'm going to approach this like Lance approached Ramadan: half-assed. I very much doubt that I'll be able to churn out a blog per day; my last one was almost two months ago.
I usually only blog after I've been turning something over in my head for a while, and thus my writings tend to pour out of me in a torrent. My blogs go long; sometimes I write them over the course of two days.
I also usually edit and revise them a couple times. It's not that I'm a perfectionist; I just believe that if I put my name to something, I want to make sure it's something I can feel good about. Not enough of my teenage students seem to feel that way, which is a topic I'm sure will be coming up frequently this month.
As such, this will be a challenge for me to keep things byte-sized (pun intended), or I'll never have time to finish them all. I'm pretty sure I have plenty of material. Every day it feels like there's a half dozen things that irk me rattling around in my brain. I shouldn't have to resort to writing what I had to eat that day, hopefully.
Again, I very well may not make through the weekend and may have to bend some rules. I may give up on it all together quickly. In the immortal words of Bart Simpson, I can't promise I'll try, but I can promise that I'll try to try.
And yes, I'm counting this one.
Anyway, there are a whole bunch of rules, but I don't feel like re-posting them. I'm going to approach this like Lance approached Ramadan: half-assed. I very much doubt that I'll be able to churn out a blog per day; my last one was almost two months ago.
I usually only blog after I've been turning something over in my head for a while, and thus my writings tend to pour out of me in a torrent. My blogs go long; sometimes I write them over the course of two days.
I also usually edit and revise them a couple times. It's not that I'm a perfectionist; I just believe that if I put my name to something, I want to make sure it's something I can feel good about. Not enough of my teenage students seem to feel that way, which is a topic I'm sure will be coming up frequently this month.
As such, this will be a challenge for me to keep things byte-sized (pun intended), or I'll never have time to finish them all. I'm pretty sure I have plenty of material. Every day it feels like there's a half dozen things that irk me rattling around in my brain. I shouldn't have to resort to writing what I had to eat that day, hopefully.
Again, I very well may not make through the weekend and may have to bend some rules. I may give up on it all together quickly. In the immortal words of Bart Simpson, I can't promise I'll try, but I can promise that I'll try to try.
And yes, I'm counting this one.
Thursday, August 6, 2009
"Racing to the Top"...of What, Again?
Let me give you a scenario. I'm going to use baseball, because sports analogies are the ones that work best for me, but you should feel free to substitute any other business you are familiar with. Please bear with me; I promise this is going somewhere.
A minor league ballclub hires you to be its manager. You've accrued enough experience, obtained solid credentials and references, nailed the interview, so they give you the job. You assume they hired you because you're creative, knowledgeable, competent, a good communicator, and a leader. You've got a lot of plans for how to make the team better.
However, on your first day on the job, you're told you're not going to be evaluated on any of these qualities. Your salary and job security rely solely on your ability to get your team to do one thing well: bunt.
You're not pleased with this. You know that bunting is important, and you were definitely going to allot significant time to teaching that skill- it's one of the fundamentals of the game, after all. But it's clearly not everything. There's a lot more to managing a baseball team than teaching players how to bunt, or even just how to hit in general.
It doesn't matter. The owner tells you that your acumen as a manager will be determined by how well your players bunt during a designated two-week span late in the year. Not the whole season: just this two-week window.
Here's where it gets even crazier. Naturally, you're going to have some players who are already pretty good at bunting, some who struggle, and a lot in between. Some of them will get better over the course of the season and some won't. Your first inclination would be to get rid of the ones who aren't coming around, right? After all, their bunting skills (or lack thereof) are determining your paycheck (or lack thereof).
No, the owner says. You're stuck with the ones you've got. Can't cut any of them, no matter how bad or disinterested at mastering the skill that will define you as a coach they may be. Don't get any ideas about trading for better bunters, either. Some teams have better bunters to start with, some have worse. That's just the luck of the draw.
Ok then, you think. You just won't let them play when you're being evaluated. You'll only put your greatest bunters out there, the ones who've responded to instruction best, during that two-week window.
Wrong again, the owner responds. They've all gotta play, and you're judged on how well they all do as a group.
You try to plead with him. Lots of them just don't give a damn about bunting, and there's nothing you can do to make them. They want to hit home runs, steal bases, make diving catches. Bunting is tedious, and they just don't care about getting better at it. Hell, some of them don't seem to even want to play baseball at all. They care more about ogling girls, spitting sunflower seeds, and planning how much weed they're going to smoke after practice. There is a sizable contingent that simply refuses to bunt, no matter what you say or do to them.
The owner is deaf to your pleas. Then comes the kicker: While you will be assessed completely based on how well your team bunts during their bunting challenge, the players themselves will not be affected at all, no matter how poorly or amazingly they perform.
Would you want to manage a team if you had to play by those rules? Or, to put it more generally, would you want to be in charge of a company where you had no input as to who's hired or fired? Where your performance would be based only on how well your employees grade out on an assessment that they not only have little-to-no impetus to prepare for, but also no reward nor punishment for how well they do on it?
It sounds ludicrous when put in those terms, doesn't it?
But this is basically what the proponents of merit pay for teachers are proposing. I can understand why. The education system has some pretty significant problems (although I'd suggest that there's still a lot more good than bad being done- the routine successes are just not as exciting as the tales of tragedy and failure). We all want accountability, someone to blame when things go wrong.
I'll be the first to admit that there are bad teachers out there. There are also bad doctors, bad chefs, and bad toll booth operators. People also have a point when they claim teachers acquire too much job security too quickly. I know of a few cases at my school where the students and the school would benefit from letting go of an incompetent teacher, but the obstacles to firing them were too great.
However, the biggest reason that these low-performing teachers make it to tenure is because there's so little competition for their low-paying, high-stress jobs. It's easy for a principal to get rid of an instructor in that teacher's first couple years. It's much harder to fill his/her shoes with someone who's going to do a better job, especially in math and science.
Merit pay, coming to the fore again under Obama's new "Race to the Top" education proposal, is popular with the general public. Not only does it give people a false sense of rewarding "good" teachers while penalizing "bad" ones, it lends itself to one of the great American pastimes, union bashing, when teachers' associations resist the idea.
Look, the teachers just want to get paid for holding their jobs another year! They don't care about the kids or how good a job they're doing! They just want to hide behind their union and pocket those lucrative paychecks!
In order to clarify why merit pay (at least the way it's been proposed so far, which is based on standardized test results) is a terrible idea, allow me to drop the analogy and clarify the realities of being a teacher:
1. You don't get to choose the classes you teach (although seniority generally dictates how closely your preferences are met). Some of us teach honors, some of us teach remedial, most of us are in the middle somewhere. Some years we have a batch of kids who are great, some years they're worse. Teaching isn't like any other profession. We're stuck (or blessed) with what we get, and we make do.
Teaching is also not like in the movies. There are no Dangerous Minds or Freedom Writers scenarios where you can turn a whole, disinterested class around. You might be able to move one or two students per year significantly one way or the other, tops. Mostly, though, they come to you at a certain level, and they leave at roughly the same level, and frustratingly, there's very little you can do to vastly improve them. You give them the necessary tools they need to move on, you hope you can impart some wisdom, perspective, skills, and intellectual curiosity onto them, and that's it.
This isn't to say some of us aren't better at it and some worse, but think about it: I'll bet you got about the same grades throughout high school in each subject, regardless of your teacher.
And yes, it's true. Their performance on the standardized tests does not affect students in any way. My district has been trying to put the results on their transcripts (which still wouldn't mean much, but it would be a small step) for years, but the parents (who can also excuse their children from the tests; you'd be surprised how often they do) have opposed it. Talk about accountability.
2. Speaking of the parents, if you read the excellent book Freakonomics, you will see analysis shows that teachers/schools have very little to do with standardized test scores. The results are nearly entirely dictated by parent income/education level. If parents have higher expectations for their kids, the kids generally do better. That's it. No mysteries. When we lament the state of education, why don't the parents of our nation's children ever come up as being a source of the problem?
If you'll permit me an anecdote, several years back I was considering switching districts so I could start making the really big bucks. I interviewed at Miramonte High School in Orinda, owners of some of the best test scores in California, much better than anything in the district I was coming from.
I asked what literature textbook they used, and they looked at me quizzically. You see, at my school we had been getting pushed to do more exercises out of the lit book, because it was aligned to the standards and thus would prepare kids to do better on the test. Miramonte said they didn't use a textbook, only novels (no standardized worksheets included with those).
How could this be? They seemingly didn't drill taking the test, but they were doing much better on it than at my school, where it was a stated priority. If you know the East Bay, you'll know the answer is as simple as buying a house in Pleasant Hill vs. buying one in Orinda. Hint: Schoolteachers can't afford to buy houses in Orinda.
3. Teachers are collaborative; a competitive system would give them reason not to help each other out. Suddenly, if I'm vying with Mr. Johnson for dollars, am I more or less inclined to share the awesome lesson plan I made about teaching Romeo and Juliet? Does this benefit the students or impair them?
This would be particularly harmful to new teachers, who must steal at least 80% of material from others, or they simply won't survive. Forty-eight percent of teachers never make it past three years on the job because they're overwhelmed. Without fellow teacher support, that number goes up. Again, who is going to replace them? I hear a lot of people talking about what an awful job we're doing, but I don't see many in line to replace us.
Add to this the possibility of widespread fraud. How's this for insanity? We'd be the ones supervising the tests, and the ones to whom the results matter most. There are myriad instances of teachers cheating in situations where the test scores affected their jobs. They either helped students with the answers or erased and filled in the right ones themselves (thanks to Freakonomics for this info, again).
I know the argument will follow that just because teachers could easily cheat doesn't negate the idea of merit pay. But how could we ever know whose test scores are real and whose are enhanced, as long as the teachers are the ones handling the evidence? The pressure would be on to keep up with one's colleagues. In addition, there's simply no money to proctor the exam any other way.
4. The reason I compared the standardized tests (in California, it's called the "STAR") to bunting in baseball is because although it's used as the be-all, end-all of student performance for lack of other quantifiable evidence, it's not the focus of our daily routine (and here I speak mostly for English teachers). According to some, it should be. If it ever happened that teaching to the test exclusively or almost exclusively became the mandate, I'm fairly certain that I would leave the profession, and I think I speak for a lot of other teachers as well.
Again, think back to your own schooling experiences. Would you have wanted your everyday English class to replicate the STAR test? Just reading Reader's Digest-sized excerpts and then answering questions about the selection? Figuring out which of the four sentences is grammatically correct? Choosing the word that best fills in the blank? Because that's all the STAR test is, a series of multiple choice questions, spread over a two-week period.
Unbelievably, there is no writing on the exam. The STAR is theoretically to be aligned to the standards, about half of which are writing, and that's not even measured.
I tend to believe there are lots of things that multiple choice can't measure. Like Shakespeare's delightfully bawdy wordplay. Like learning about empathy from Boo Radley and Tom Robinson. Like John Proctor's impassioned speech, explaining why he'd rather hang for being a witch than lose his name's integrity. Like Holden's voice as he rambles around New York City, an adolescent trying to find his place in the world. Like Huck learning the nature of friendship from a slave named Jim, pant cuffs rolled up, floating lazily along the Mississippi.
Think back now. Did any of those things make a difference in the type of person you are today, or was it your performance on a multiple choice, state-issued test? Did the teachers you considered as having the most positive impact on your life spend a lot of reading 250-word excerpts and then answering questions about the passage's main idea? Did you learn the most from an instructor who told you to turn to page whatever in your textbook and fill out the standardized worksheet, or was it someone who made these stories come to life and explained their relevance to our own existence?
How on earth does merit pay measure that?
A minor league ballclub hires you to be its manager. You've accrued enough experience, obtained solid credentials and references, nailed the interview, so they give you the job. You assume they hired you because you're creative, knowledgeable, competent, a good communicator, and a leader. You've got a lot of plans for how to make the team better.
However, on your first day on the job, you're told you're not going to be evaluated on any of these qualities. Your salary and job security rely solely on your ability to get your team to do one thing well: bunt.
You're not pleased with this. You know that bunting is important, and you were definitely going to allot significant time to teaching that skill- it's one of the fundamentals of the game, after all. But it's clearly not everything. There's a lot more to managing a baseball team than teaching players how to bunt, or even just how to hit in general.
It doesn't matter. The owner tells you that your acumen as a manager will be determined by how well your players bunt during a designated two-week span late in the year. Not the whole season: just this two-week window.
Here's where it gets even crazier. Naturally, you're going to have some players who are already pretty good at bunting, some who struggle, and a lot in between. Some of them will get better over the course of the season and some won't. Your first inclination would be to get rid of the ones who aren't coming around, right? After all, their bunting skills (or lack thereof) are determining your paycheck (or lack thereof).
No, the owner says. You're stuck with the ones you've got. Can't cut any of them, no matter how bad or disinterested at mastering the skill that will define you as a coach they may be. Don't get any ideas about trading for better bunters, either. Some teams have better bunters to start with, some have worse. That's just the luck of the draw.
Ok then, you think. You just won't let them play when you're being evaluated. You'll only put your greatest bunters out there, the ones who've responded to instruction best, during that two-week window.
Wrong again, the owner responds. They've all gotta play, and you're judged on how well they all do as a group.
You try to plead with him. Lots of them just don't give a damn about bunting, and there's nothing you can do to make them. They want to hit home runs, steal bases, make diving catches. Bunting is tedious, and they just don't care about getting better at it. Hell, some of them don't seem to even want to play baseball at all. They care more about ogling girls, spitting sunflower seeds, and planning how much weed they're going to smoke after practice. There is a sizable contingent that simply refuses to bunt, no matter what you say or do to them.
The owner is deaf to your pleas. Then comes the kicker: While you will be assessed completely based on how well your team bunts during their bunting challenge, the players themselves will not be affected at all, no matter how poorly or amazingly they perform.
Would you want to manage a team if you had to play by those rules? Or, to put it more generally, would you want to be in charge of a company where you had no input as to who's hired or fired? Where your performance would be based only on how well your employees grade out on an assessment that they not only have little-to-no impetus to prepare for, but also no reward nor punishment for how well they do on it?
It sounds ludicrous when put in those terms, doesn't it?
But this is basically what the proponents of merit pay for teachers are proposing. I can understand why. The education system has some pretty significant problems (although I'd suggest that there's still a lot more good than bad being done- the routine successes are just not as exciting as the tales of tragedy and failure). We all want accountability, someone to blame when things go wrong.
I'll be the first to admit that there are bad teachers out there. There are also bad doctors, bad chefs, and bad toll booth operators. People also have a point when they claim teachers acquire too much job security too quickly. I know of a few cases at my school where the students and the school would benefit from letting go of an incompetent teacher, but the obstacles to firing them were too great.
However, the biggest reason that these low-performing teachers make it to tenure is because there's so little competition for their low-paying, high-stress jobs. It's easy for a principal to get rid of an instructor in that teacher's first couple years. It's much harder to fill his/her shoes with someone who's going to do a better job, especially in math and science.
Merit pay, coming to the fore again under Obama's new "Race to the Top" education proposal, is popular with the general public. Not only does it give people a false sense of rewarding "good" teachers while penalizing "bad" ones, it lends itself to one of the great American pastimes, union bashing, when teachers' associations resist the idea.
Look, the teachers just want to get paid for holding their jobs another year! They don't care about the kids or how good a job they're doing! They just want to hide behind their union and pocket those lucrative paychecks!
In order to clarify why merit pay (at least the way it's been proposed so far, which is based on standardized test results) is a terrible idea, allow me to drop the analogy and clarify the realities of being a teacher:
1. You don't get to choose the classes you teach (although seniority generally dictates how closely your preferences are met). Some of us teach honors, some of us teach remedial, most of us are in the middle somewhere. Some years we have a batch of kids who are great, some years they're worse. Teaching isn't like any other profession. We're stuck (or blessed) with what we get, and we make do.
Teaching is also not like in the movies. There are no Dangerous Minds or Freedom Writers scenarios where you can turn a whole, disinterested class around. You might be able to move one or two students per year significantly one way or the other, tops. Mostly, though, they come to you at a certain level, and they leave at roughly the same level, and frustratingly, there's very little you can do to vastly improve them. You give them the necessary tools they need to move on, you hope you can impart some wisdom, perspective, skills, and intellectual curiosity onto them, and that's it.
This isn't to say some of us aren't better at it and some worse, but think about it: I'll bet you got about the same grades throughout high school in each subject, regardless of your teacher.
And yes, it's true. Their performance on the standardized tests does not affect students in any way. My district has been trying to put the results on their transcripts (which still wouldn't mean much, but it would be a small step) for years, but the parents (who can also excuse their children from the tests; you'd be surprised how often they do) have opposed it. Talk about accountability.
2. Speaking of the parents, if you read the excellent book Freakonomics, you will see analysis shows that teachers/schools have very little to do with standardized test scores. The results are nearly entirely dictated by parent income/education level. If parents have higher expectations for their kids, the kids generally do better. That's it. No mysteries. When we lament the state of education, why don't the parents of our nation's children ever come up as being a source of the problem?
If you'll permit me an anecdote, several years back I was considering switching districts so I could start making the really big bucks. I interviewed at Miramonte High School in Orinda, owners of some of the best test scores in California, much better than anything in the district I was coming from.
I asked what literature textbook they used, and they looked at me quizzically. You see, at my school we had been getting pushed to do more exercises out of the lit book, because it was aligned to the standards and thus would prepare kids to do better on the test. Miramonte said they didn't use a textbook, only novels (no standardized worksheets included with those).
How could this be? They seemingly didn't drill taking the test, but they were doing much better on it than at my school, where it was a stated priority. If you know the East Bay, you'll know the answer is as simple as buying a house in Pleasant Hill vs. buying one in Orinda. Hint: Schoolteachers can't afford to buy houses in Orinda.
3. Teachers are collaborative; a competitive system would give them reason not to help each other out. Suddenly, if I'm vying with Mr. Johnson for dollars, am I more or less inclined to share the awesome lesson plan I made about teaching Romeo and Juliet? Does this benefit the students or impair them?
This would be particularly harmful to new teachers, who must steal at least 80% of material from others, or they simply won't survive. Forty-eight percent of teachers never make it past three years on the job because they're overwhelmed. Without fellow teacher support, that number goes up. Again, who is going to replace them? I hear a lot of people talking about what an awful job we're doing, but I don't see many in line to replace us.
Add to this the possibility of widespread fraud. How's this for insanity? We'd be the ones supervising the tests, and the ones to whom the results matter most. There are myriad instances of teachers cheating in situations where the test scores affected their jobs. They either helped students with the answers or erased and filled in the right ones themselves (thanks to Freakonomics for this info, again).
I know the argument will follow that just because teachers could easily cheat doesn't negate the idea of merit pay. But how could we ever know whose test scores are real and whose are enhanced, as long as the teachers are the ones handling the evidence? The pressure would be on to keep up with one's colleagues. In addition, there's simply no money to proctor the exam any other way.
4. The reason I compared the standardized tests (in California, it's called the "STAR") to bunting in baseball is because although it's used as the be-all, end-all of student performance for lack of other quantifiable evidence, it's not the focus of our daily routine (and here I speak mostly for English teachers). According to some, it should be. If it ever happened that teaching to the test exclusively or almost exclusively became the mandate, I'm fairly certain that I would leave the profession, and I think I speak for a lot of other teachers as well.
Again, think back to your own schooling experiences. Would you have wanted your everyday English class to replicate the STAR test? Just reading Reader's Digest-sized excerpts and then answering questions about the selection? Figuring out which of the four sentences is grammatically correct? Choosing the word that best fills in the blank? Because that's all the STAR test is, a series of multiple choice questions, spread over a two-week period.
Unbelievably, there is no writing on the exam. The STAR is theoretically to be aligned to the standards, about half of which are writing, and that's not even measured.
I tend to believe there are lots of things that multiple choice can't measure. Like Shakespeare's delightfully bawdy wordplay. Like learning about empathy from Boo Radley and Tom Robinson. Like John Proctor's impassioned speech, explaining why he'd rather hang for being a witch than lose his name's integrity. Like Holden's voice as he rambles around New York City, an adolescent trying to find his place in the world. Like Huck learning the nature of friendship from a slave named Jim, pant cuffs rolled up, floating lazily along the Mississippi.
Think back now. Did any of those things make a difference in the type of person you are today, or was it your performance on a multiple choice, state-issued test? Did the teachers you considered as having the most positive impact on your life spend a lot of reading 250-word excerpts and then answering questions about the passage's main idea? Did you learn the most from an instructor who told you to turn to page whatever in your textbook and fill out the standardized worksheet, or was it someone who made these stories come to life and explained their relevance to our own existence?
How on earth does merit pay measure that?
Friday, July 31, 2009
Socialism: Adendum
If you even casually keep up with current events, you can probably guess what inspired the satire in the post below this one.
Like a lot of people, I'm in favor of a single-payer, government-run health care system. Yes, socialized medicine. There is, of course, huge controversy over this, mostly because people fear the word "socialism" without understanding what it means. They just know it's supposed to be bad, a close cousin to that arch-nemesis to our freedoms: communism.
What I tried to point out in my last post is that we already revere and enjoy several aspects of socialism; we just don't refer to them that way because they're so deeply ingrained in our way of life. Police and fire departments, public education, and even the U.S. Armed Forces are, by any definition, socialist institutions. They are funded and run completely by the government and provided at no cost to citizens (other than, of course, taxes).
We have set up these systems because as a society we have agreed that certain things should be made available to all citizens, regardless of income level. Everyone is entitled to police protection, fire services, education, and protection from threats both foreign and domestic. I doubt that even conservatives would find fault with that.
Thus, the obvious question: Why aren't we entitled to health care...you know, life itself?
The right does their usual "The government can't do anything right!" rap (which is a self-fulfiling prophecy), conveniently ignoring that they're the biggest supporters of increased spending for the U.S. Military, by far the largest chunk of federal government spending. Why do they have so much faith in the government when it comes to guns and bombs but not surgery and bandages? It also doesn't acknowledge whom we entrust with our most lauded citizens: veterans. Where do they get their health care? I don't need to tell you the answer, do I?
What really drives me crazy is that for the first time in a long time, the Democrats, supposedly the party of the common man, has complete, fillibuster-proof control. They have another year-and-a-half to get things done. Say what you may about Bush, but even when he didn't have this majority, he bent the country to his will. He and Cheney circled their own party's wagons and bullied enough Democrats into voting for wars, tax cuts, etc.
Every day, I see Obama's promise of "affordable health care for all" get watered down just a little bit more. And mostly it's because the Dems continue to let the Republicans (especially the pundits with their legions of unthinking dittoheads) continue to frame the debate. They just scream "socialism!" over and over again until the more conservative Dems get cold feet and start eliminating any provision that would substantially overhaul the system, which was sort of the whole point in the first place.
Think about that for a second. How amazing is it that the Democrats are allowing policy to be dictated to them by a party whose approval rating is at historic lows? Will they ever grow a spine and get it together?
Here's my first suggestion: Obama puts those brilliant oratory skills to work in order to speak rationally and sensibly about socialism. He points out all the socialist stuff we already have and makes the case that health care shouldn't be a for-profit industry, the same way the police, fire, education, and military systems shouldn't be (the fact that the military is becoming scandalously privatized is the subject for another blog). Wouldn't that appeal to the majority of the American public?
Wanna hear something really depressing? What prompted me to write all this was a recent viewing of the Ted Kennedy documentary on HBO. They showed a speech he gave in 1978 (a curly brown-haired Bill Clinton introduced him) about health care. Teddy spoke passionately about the need for all Americans to have quality health care, not just well-to-dos like his famous family.
It's over 30 years later, and I'm hearing the exact same points being made, with zero progress. In fact, things are much worse. You don't need the stats thrown at you again; it's well known that the U.S. spends by far the most on health costs and yet lags behind dozens of other countries in actual health benefits, life expectancy, etc.
Are Americans really so thick-headed that they would continue under this abysmal system rather than accept that the most important part of being guaranteed life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness just might be the "life" part?
Sadly, I think the answer is yes. But at least we'll have struck down further socialism. Hooray.
Like a lot of people, I'm in favor of a single-payer, government-run health care system. Yes, socialized medicine. There is, of course, huge controversy over this, mostly because people fear the word "socialism" without understanding what it means. They just know it's supposed to be bad, a close cousin to that arch-nemesis to our freedoms: communism.
What I tried to point out in my last post is that we already revere and enjoy several aspects of socialism; we just don't refer to them that way because they're so deeply ingrained in our way of life. Police and fire departments, public education, and even the U.S. Armed Forces are, by any definition, socialist institutions. They are funded and run completely by the government and provided at no cost to citizens (other than, of course, taxes).
We have set up these systems because as a society we have agreed that certain things should be made available to all citizens, regardless of income level. Everyone is entitled to police protection, fire services, education, and protection from threats both foreign and domestic. I doubt that even conservatives would find fault with that.
Thus, the obvious question: Why aren't we entitled to health care...you know, life itself?
The right does their usual "The government can't do anything right!" rap (which is a self-fulfiling prophecy), conveniently ignoring that they're the biggest supporters of increased spending for the U.S. Military, by far the largest chunk of federal government spending. Why do they have so much faith in the government when it comes to guns and bombs but not surgery and bandages? It also doesn't acknowledge whom we entrust with our most lauded citizens: veterans. Where do they get their health care? I don't need to tell you the answer, do I?
What really drives me crazy is that for the first time in a long time, the Democrats, supposedly the party of the common man, has complete, fillibuster-proof control. They have another year-and-a-half to get things done. Say what you may about Bush, but even when he didn't have this majority, he bent the country to his will. He and Cheney circled their own party's wagons and bullied enough Democrats into voting for wars, tax cuts, etc.
Every day, I see Obama's promise of "affordable health care for all" get watered down just a little bit more. And mostly it's because the Dems continue to let the Republicans (especially the pundits with their legions of unthinking dittoheads) continue to frame the debate. They just scream "socialism!" over and over again until the more conservative Dems get cold feet and start eliminating any provision that would substantially overhaul the system, which was sort of the whole point in the first place.
Think about that for a second. How amazing is it that the Democrats are allowing policy to be dictated to them by a party whose approval rating is at historic lows? Will they ever grow a spine and get it together?
Here's my first suggestion: Obama puts those brilliant oratory skills to work in order to speak rationally and sensibly about socialism. He points out all the socialist stuff we already have and makes the case that health care shouldn't be a for-profit industry, the same way the police, fire, education, and military systems shouldn't be (the fact that the military is becoming scandalously privatized is the subject for another blog). Wouldn't that appeal to the majority of the American public?
Wanna hear something really depressing? What prompted me to write all this was a recent viewing of the Ted Kennedy documentary on HBO. They showed a speech he gave in 1978 (a curly brown-haired Bill Clinton introduced him) about health care. Teddy spoke passionately about the need for all Americans to have quality health care, not just well-to-dos like his famous family.
It's over 30 years later, and I'm hearing the exact same points being made, with zero progress. In fact, things are much worse. You don't need the stats thrown at you again; it's well known that the U.S. spends by far the most on health costs and yet lags behind dozens of other countries in actual health benefits, life expectancy, etc.
Are Americans really so thick-headed that they would continue under this abysmal system rather than accept that the most important part of being guaranteed life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness just might be the "life" part?
Sadly, I think the answer is yes. But at least we'll have struck down further socialism. Hooray.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)